Licensed Professional Engineers |
Search/

Request a free quote

Electrical

Selective Coordination: What the NEC Requires and What the AHJ Needs to See

Where the NEC requires selective coordination (700.32, 701.32, 708.54, 620.62), what counts as selective, and what the AHJ needs in a submittal.

By Dreiym Engineering

Subject Matter Expert: Brian J. Brackensick, M.S., P.E.

Technical review: Brian J. Brackensick, M.S., P.E.

Published 9 min read

Electrical panels and enclosures mounted on a concrete wall with conduitElectrical panels and enclosures mounted on a concrete wall with conduit
Contents
  1. Coordination vs. Selective Coordination
  2. Where the NEC Requires Selective Coordination
  3. The Supply Side Counts Too
  4. How Selectivity Is Shown
  5. What the AHJ Needs to See
  6. Selective Coordination and Arc Flash
  7. Keeping It Valid After Changes
  8. Common Mistakes
  9. Frequently Asked Questions
  10. How Dreiym Engineering Can Help

Selective coordination means that when a fault or overload happens, only the overcurrent device protecting the faulted circuit opens, and this has to hold for every overcurrent from overload up to the maximum available fault current. The 2023 NEC® requires it for emergency systems (700.32), legally required standby systems (701.32), critical operations power systems (708.54) and elevators where more than one driving machine disconnecting means is supplied by the same source (620.62). Health care essential electrical systems have their own, narrower coordination rule in 517.31(G).

The NEC also says who decides and what has to be kept: the selective coordination has to be selected by a licensed professional engineer or other qualified person, documented, and made available to the people who design, install, inspect, maintain and operate the system. Below we cover what counts as selective, where the code requires it, what a submittal for the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ) should contain, and how to keep a system coordinated after it changes.

Coordination vs. Selective Coordination

Every electrical system is coordinated to some degree: the device nearest a fault is meant to open first. A coordination study sets breakers, fuses, trip units and relays so that happens as often as practical, while still protecting cables and transformers and keeping arc flash incident energy in check.

Selective coordination is stricter. The NEC Article 100 definition requires the overcurrent protective devices and their ratings or settings to be selected and installed “for the full range of available overcurrents, from overload to the maximum available fault current, and for the full range of overcurrent protective device opening times associated with those overcurrents.” There is no cutoff time. A design that is selective down to 0.1 second, or 0.01 second, but not for faults that clear faster, isn’t selectively coordinated.

General coordinationSelective coordinationHealth care essential electrical system
Where it appliesAny system, as a design choiceSystems where the NEC requires it (Articles 700, 701, 708, 620 and others)517.31(G)
Range of currentsAs far as practicalOverload to the maximum available fault currentFaults lasting longer than 0.1 second
Trade-offs allowedSelectivity balanced against equipment protection and arc flashOnly the exceptions the code listsFaults that clear in under 0.1 second may open more than one device

Where the NEC Requires Selective Coordination

Section numbers below are from the 2023 NEC. Your AHJ enforces a specific edition, sometimes with local amendments, so check which one applies.

NEC sectionSystemWhat has to coordinate
700.32Emergency systemsEmergency system overcurrent protective devices (OCPDs) with all supply-side and load-side OCPDs
701.32Legally required standby systemsLegally required standby OCPDs with all supply-side and load-side OCPDs
708.54Critical operations power systemsCritical operations power system OCPDs with all supply-side and load-side OCPDs
620.62Elevators, where more than one driving machine disconnecting means is supplied by the same sourceThe OCPDs in each disconnecting means with any other supply-side OCPDs
517.31(G)Health care essential electrical systemsOCPDs serving the essential electrical system, for faults lasting longer than 0.1 second

Articles 645 (critical operations data systems) and 695 (fire pumps in multibuilding campus-style complexes) also contain selective coordination requirements. Article 702, optional standby systems, does not require it.

In the 2023 NEC, 700.32, 701.32 and 708.54 each have three parts: (A) General, the requirement itself and who selects it; (B) Replacements, which requires coordination to be reevaluated when OCPDs are replaced; and (C) Modifications, which requires reevaluation after modifications, additions or deletions to the system. The 2026 NEC keeps this structure in 700.32 and adds the same replacement and modification rules for elevators in 620.62(B) and (C).

The one exception

Under 700.32, 701.32, 708.54 and 620.62, selective coordination isn’t required between two overcurrent devices in series if no loads are connected in parallel with the downstream device. A feeder breaker feeding a single panel main breaker, with nothing else on that feeder, is the typical case: whichever of the two opens, the same loads lose power.

The Supply Side Counts Too

The most common gap in a selective coordination study is stopping at the transfer switch. Emergency system devices have to coordinate with every supply-side device, which includes the devices on the normal source as well as the generator side. A fault on an emergency branch circuit that trips the service main, or the feeder to the transfer switch, takes out the normal source the emergency loads are using at that moment.

Devices that aren’t part of the emergency system don’t have to coordinate with each other. In Figure 1, the feeder to the transfer switch’s normal side and the service main are normal system devices, so they don’t have to coordinate with one another, but both have to coordinate with the emergency feeder and branch devices below the transfer switch.

One-line diagram of a simple emergency system. The utility feeds service main A and feeder B to the transfer switch's normal side; the generator feeds generator main E and feeder F to its emergency side; the transfer switch feeds emergency panel feeder C and branch devices D. D must selectively coordinate with C, F, E, B and A; C with F, E, B and A; F with E. B does not have to coordinate with A because B is not an emergency system device.
Figure 1. Which devices have to selectively coordinate in a simple emergency system: the emergency feeder and branch devices coordinate with every supply-side device on both the normal and the generator source.

How Selectivity Is Shown

A study usually shows selectivity in three ways, depending on the devices:

  • Time-current curves (TCCs). The curves of each pair of devices in series are plotted together, up to the available fault current at the downstream device. Where the curves don’t overlap at any current up to that value, the pair is selective. Curves are typically drawn down to 0.01 second, so they can’t show what happens when both devices operate in their instantaneous range.
  • Manufacturer selectivity tables. Circuit breaker manufacturers publish tested combinations of upstream and downstream breakers that are selective up to a stated current. Where the available fault current is at or below that value, the pair is selective even if the curves appear to cross.
  • Fuse ratio tables. Fuse manufacturers publish minimum ampere ratios between upstream and downstream fuses of given classes, selective up to a stated fault current.

All three depend on the available fault current at each device, so the short circuit analysis comes first. Emergency and standby systems have at least two sources, and a generator usually delivers much less fault current than the utility, so the study checks each device against each source that can feed it.

Two time-current plots for an illustrative 100 A branch breaker below a 400 A feeder breaker, with the 18 kA available fault current marked. In (a) the feeder breaker has a 0.3 second short-time delay and its curve stays clear of the branch breaker's curve up to 18 kA, so the pair is selective. In (b) the feeder breaker's instantaneous trip at 4 kA overlaps the branch breaker's instantaneous region from 4 kA to 18 kA, so both can trip.
Figure 2. Two breakers in series on a time-current plot: (a) curves that stay apart up to the available fault current are selective; (b) instantaneous regions that overlap below the available fault current are not, unless a tested selectivity table shows otherwise.

Related service

Protection & Coordination

Time-current curves, relay settings, AHJ documents

Request a free quote

What the AHJ Needs to See

The NEC requires the selection to be documented and made available to those authorized to design, install, inspect, maintain and operate the system. AHJs differ in how much they ask for at plan review. Some, such as Miami-Dade County, use a selective coordination form that the engineer of record signs and seals. A submittal that answers the plan reviewer’s questions without a phone call usually contains:

  • The code basis: the NEC edition, the sections that apply, and which systems and loads are emergency, legally required standby, critical operations or elevator loads.
  • A one-line diagram of the systems covered, showing the normal and alternate sources, transfer switches, and every OCPD in each path.
  • Available fault current at each OCPD, from each source that can feed it.
  • A device schedule with manufacturer, type, frame and sensor or fuse rating, and trip unit for each device.
  • The analysis for each pair of devices in series: TCC plots up to the available fault current, the manufacturer selectivity table or fuse ratio used, and a clear pass for each pair.
  • Any exception used, with the devices it applies to and why no loads are in parallel with the downstream device.
  • A settings table for every adjustable device, in a form the installer can set from and the inspector can check.
  • The responsible engineer’s signature, with a PE stamp where the AHJ or the owner requires one.

The definition says “selection and installation,” and adjustable breakers ship from the factory with default settings. Field verification that each device is set as the study requires is part of the job, and the record of it belongs with the study.

Selective Coordination and Arc Flash

Coordination usually works by delaying upstream devices so downstream devices clear first. That delay also lets an arc at the upstream equipment burn longer, which raises the incident energy on its label. The two goals have to be studied together, not one after the other.

Designers reconcile them with zone-selective interlocking, energy-reducing maintenance switching, differential protection, and current-limiting fuses applied with their selectivity ratios. For circuit breakers whose trip can be set to 1200 A or more, NEC 240.87 already requires an arc energy reduction method, and several of the methods it lists work with selective coordination rather than against it. A combined study on one model, with arc flash studies run against the final settings, shows whether the system meets both.

Keeping It Valid After Changes

Selective coordination isn’t a one-time calculation. Under 700.32(B) and (C), and the matching parts of 701.32 and 708.54, it has to be reevaluated when OCPDs are replaced and when the system is modified. Changes that call for a new look include:

  • Replacing a breaker, trip unit or fuse, even “like for like” from a different manufacturer or fuse class
  • Changing a trip setting during troubleshooting
  • Adding a feeder, panel or transfer switch to the emergency system
  • Replacing the generator or the utility transformer, which changes the available fault current
  • Adding a downstream device that creates a new pair in series

Keeping the study model current, and reviewing it on the same cycle as the short-circuit and arc flash studies, is easier than rebuilding it after a failed inspection. Our post on NFPA 70B requirements covers how those reviews fit into an electrical maintenance program, and our post on emergency power systems covers the systems themselves.

Common Mistakes

  1. Stopping at the transfer switch and leaving out the normal-source devices upstream of it.
  2. Checking only the utility source and not the generator, or the reverse.
  3. Relying on curves alone where both devices operate in their instantaneous range.
  4. Applying the 0.1 second health care criterion to an Article 700 emergency system.
  5. Leaving adjustable breakers at factory settings, or never recording the installed settings.
  6. Replacing a device without a reevaluation, which 700.32(B) requires.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the 0.1 second rule apply to emergency systems?

No. The 0.1 second criterion is in 517.31(G) for health care essential electrical systems. Article 700 emergency systems have to be selectively coordinated over the full range of overcurrents and opening times in the Article 100 definition.

Who is allowed to select the selective coordination?

The NEC says a licensed professional engineer or other qualified persons engaged primarily in the design, installation or maintenance of electrical systems. The selection has to be documented and made available to those who design, install, inspect, maintain and operate the system.

Do we need a new study when we replace one breaker?

The code requires the coordination to be reevaluated when emergency, legally required standby or critical operations power system OCPDs are replaced. If the existing study is current, that is usually a check of the new device against its neighbors rather than a new study.

Does an optional standby generator need selective coordination?

Article 702 doesn’t require it. Where one generator also feeds emergency or legally required standby loads, a fault on an optional standby feeder that trips the generator main takes those loads down too, so designers often coordinate those devices as well.

Can selective coordination make the arc flash hazard worse?

It can, because delaying upstream devices lets an arc there last longer. Zone-selective interlocking, maintenance switching and differential protection are common ways to keep both selectivity and acceptable incident energy.

How Dreiym Engineering Can Help

We perform protective device coordination studies, including AHJ-ready selective coordination documentation and medium-voltage protective relay settings, modeled in ETAP® and SKM together with the short circuit analysis and arc flash studies. Our studies are led by Brian J. Brackensick, M.S., P.E., with field data collection by Ruben A. Rodriguez. Our engineers are licensed Professional Engineers with active and past licensure in multiple states, and reports are PE-stamped where required. Contact us or call (866) 621-6920 for a free quote. We typically respond within one business day.

Talk to an engineer about your project

We typically respond within one business day.

Request a free quoteor call (866) 621-6920