Consulting Areas
Forensic Lighting Analysis
We typically respond within one business day.
Inadequate Lighting in Slip, Trip and Fall Cases
A forensic lighting analysis determines whether the lighting where an incident happened was adequate: what the light levels and conditions were at the time, whether the lighting met the codes and recommended practices that applied, and whether inadequate lighting was a contributing condition. It is most often needed in slip, trip and fall and other premises liability cases, on stairs, walkways, parking lots and building exits, and in workplace incidents.
Our licensed Professional Engineers measure light levels at the scene, document the lighting system and the conditions that affected it, and report their findings to insurers, adjusters, attorneys and property owners. For attorneys who need a lighting expert witness, our engineers write expert reports and testify in depositions and at trial. Forensic lighting analysis is one of our forensic engineering services.
Submit an assignment or contact us for a free quote. We typically respond within one business day.
Where lighting is at issue
- Parking lots and garages: pole and wall-mounted lighting, dark areas between fixtures, curbs, wheel stops and changes in level.
- Stairs, steps and ramps: the lighting on treads, landings, stair edges and changes in level.
- Walkways and entrances: sidewalks, building entrances, lobbies and the path from parking to the door.
- Exits and egress paths: corridors, exit stairs and the path outside to a public way.
- Emergency lighting and exit signs: whether they came on and stayed on when normal power failed.
- Workplaces: work areas, aisles, loading docks and warehouses, including glare and flicker.
When the incident also involves the walking surface, stairs or equipment, see our injury and accident investigation page.
Measuring and documenting the lighting
We inspect the scene as soon as possible, before lamps are replaced, fixtures are repaired or timers are reset, and document it as found. Light levels are measured at the walking surface, along the path the person took and at the spot where the incident happened, under conditions as close as possible to those at the time. We also document:
- Each fixture, its type, mounting and condition, and whether it was working, dim, flickering, damaged or blocked by trees, signs or stored materials.
- Lamp outages, and when lamps were last replaced.
- Controls: photocells, timers, switches and occupancy sensors, their settings and whether they turned the lights on when they should have.
- Other conditions at the spot that may have played a part, such as the walking surface and changes in level.
Ordinary photographs don’t reliably show how bright or dark a scene looked, because a camera adjusts its exposure, so the measurements carry the weight.
Codes and recommended practices
What lighting was required depends on the property, its occupancy and the codes the jurisdiction had adopted. Building codes and NFPA 101®, Life Safety Code®, where adopted, set minimum lighting for the means of egress, the path people use to leave a building, and for emergency lighting when normal power fails. In the editions most often adopted, NFPA 101 calls for floors and walking surfaces along the means of egress to be lit to at least 1 footcandle measured at the floor, with more for new stairs, and for emergency lighting to provide, for at least 1.5 hours, an initial average of at least 1 footcandle and at least 0.1 footcandle at any point along the path of egress. The edition the jurisdiction had adopted governs, and the requirements vary with the edition and the occupancy.
For parking lots, sidewalks, entrances and work areas, codes often set no specific light level. There, the recommended practices of the Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) describe the light levels and uniformity generally recommended for the setting, and local ordinances, leases or company standards may also apply. A recommended practice isn’t mandatory unless it has been adopted or agreed to, but it shows what is generally considered reasonable. Falling short of a requirement doesn’t by itself mean the lighting caused a fall; the analysis has to connect the lighting to the incident.
Reconstructing the conditions at the time
Incidents are rarely investigated at the same hour, in the same weather, with the same lamps working. We work out the conditions at the time from the time of day and the sunset and twilight times for the date, the weather, records of lamp outages, repairs and replacements, the control settings, and changes made since, such as new fixtures or trimmed trees. Measurements can then be taken with the lighting set up as it was, or adjusted for what changed.
Lighting expert witness work
Each report states what we measured and documented, how the conditions at the time were worked out, and the basis for each opinion. We also assess existing lighting before an incident, to find dark areas, outages, flicker and glare and recommend improvements. Our article on forensic lighting analysis and workplace safety covers that side.
Current CVs and our rate schedule are available on request.
When you contact us, you talk directly with an engineer who can discuss your case. Our offices are in Coldspring, Texas and Westcliffe, Colorado, and we work nationwide. Reports are PE-stamped where required, and we also accept consulting-only (non-testifying) retentions.
Submit an assignment or contact us for a free quote. We typically respond within one business day.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much lighting is required for a walkway, stair or parking lot?
It depends on where it is and which codes the jurisdiction had adopted. Along a building’s means of egress, the building code and NFPA 101, where adopted, set minimums; in the editions most often adopted, NFPA 101 calls for at least 1 footcandle measured at the floor, with more for new stairs. Parking lots, sidewalks and many other areas often have no code minimum, and the IES recommended practices, local ordinances or the owner’s own standards are used instead.
Can lighting be evaluated if the fixtures or lamps have changed since the incident?
Often, yes. Maintenance records, work orders, photographs and witness accounts show what changed, and measurements can be taken with the lighting set up as it was, or adjusted for the differences. That is why records of lamp replacements, repairs and control settings should be kept.
Does poor lighting mean the property owner is liable?
Not on its own. The engineering analysis shows what the lighting was, how it compared with what applied, and whether it was a contributing condition. Liability is decided by the court, and lighting is usually one of several conditions considered, along with the walking surface, the hazard and what the person was doing.
What should be kept after a fall where lighting may be a factor?
Don’t replace lamps, repair fixtures or change timer and photocell settings until the lighting has been documented. Keep maintenance and lamp replacement records, work orders, incident reports, photographs and surveillance video, which is often recorded over after a set time.
Related Reading
- How Forensic Lighting Analysis Boosts Productivity and Workplace Safety
Workplace lighting levels in foot-candles: OSHA 1926.56 minimums for construction sites, IES recommended practices, and how a lighting survey measures them.
Have a loss to investigate?
We typically respond within one business day.

