Licensed Professional Engineers |
Search/

Request a free quote

Selected Projects

Commercial Electrical Investigations, Lake Charles Area (2021)

We typically respond within one business day.

Project at a glanceDE-PRJ-8114

Practice
Forensic
Location
Lake Charles, LA
Service
Electrical investigation
Client
Confidential

Commercial Electrical Investigations, Lake Charles Area (2021)

Our forensic team worked two commercial electrical investigations in the Lake Charles area in 2021, both at retail and assembly properties. Details of the parties and the properties are confidential.

Damage at a commercial property

Documenting a commercial loss. The two properties are in the same area, but each got an independent examination.

When a commercial building’s electrical system is suspect

In a commercial building, a lot of electrical equipment serves a lot of people and a business that can’t run without it. So when the electrical system comes under suspicion, finding what failed is only the start. We also have to work out what the failure affected and what is safe to re-energize.

Following the current through the building

We start at the service equipment, where power comes in, and work through the distribution and branch circuits to the loads. At each stage we record the condition of what we find and rule out explanations the physical evidence doesn’t support. Our in-house laboratory in Texas handles controlled analysis of parts that need a closer look, including non-destructive X-ray examination.

Why these buildings are harder than a house

A house has one service and one panel, and its wiring usually dates from one period. A retail or assembly property has a service, a main distribution panel and subpanels feeding separate tenant spaces. It also has thirty years of changes made by different electricians for different occupants. Signage, refrigeration, kitchen equipment, rooftop HVAC and tenant build-outs get added, then abandoned in place. Circuits get repurposed and the labels stop being true. That kind of work on top of the original design is normal in these buildings, so we have to establish what was installed before we can judge what failed.

How the building is used raises the stakes. Retail and assembly spaces have life safety systems, egress lighting and fire alarm circuits on the same distribution as everything else, and business interruption starts the moment the power goes off. The owner has to know what is safe to re-energize. The insurer and any counsel involved need to know what failed and why.

Off-white and tan electrical boxes on a gray block wall, conduit and pipe above, flexible conduit to an open box of cables

Electrical enclosures and conduit. Part of the job is separating damage that caused an event from damage the event left behind.

Reading arc damage and breaker positions

Electrical evidence is easy to read too much into. Arcing damage on a conductor shows it was energized and faulted at that point. It doesn’t settle whether the electrical system started anything. A fire moving through a building damages insulation as it goes, and that produces arcing too. Much of the analysis comes down to telling arcing from melting, and arcing that caused an event from arcing that the event caused. Another large part is the state of the overcurrent protection. A breaker that tripped did its job, and a device found closed on a faulted circuit raises a different question from one found open.

We don’t treat a gap in the evidence as proof either way. Each possible explanation is checked against the physical evidence and either supported or ruled out, and we only reach a conclusion that has survived that testing. Anything that needs opening gets a controlled examination in our in-house laboratory, and non-destructive X-ray imaging lets us document its internal condition without consuming the evidence.

Our work at both properties

At each property we investigated the electrical system and documented our findings. Licensed Professional Engineers prepared the written engineering opinions we delivered.

Who’s waiting on the answer

A commercial loss starts the same clock for the business and its insurer, and for any counsel involved. All of them will build on what the electrical investigation finds, so it has to be careful work they can defend. Our forensic electrical engineering practice covers Texas, Colorado, Louisiana and the surrounding states.

Get your project started

We typically respond within one business day.

Request a free quoteor call (866) 621-6920

Newsletter

Engineering notes from Dreiym

New articles on power systems, corrosion and forensic engineering, by email when we publish. Free account included: keep your calculator work, reports and exports in one place.

One email per new article. Unsubscribe in one click.