Frye vs. Daubert: Modern Standards for Forensic Engineering Testimony
Frye vs. Daubert: learn how each expert testimony standard works, which courts apply them, and how forensic engineers prepare admissible evidence.


Contents
- A Quick History of Daubert vs. Frye
- Background on Frye and Daubert Standards
- How Federal and State Courts Differ
- Implications for Forensic Engineering Practice
- How the Standards Play Out in Practice
- The Role of the Judge as a Gatekeeper
- Frequently Asked Questions About Frye vs. Daubert
- Honest Testimony Under Either Standard
Our role as an experienced forensic engineering firm dealing in everything from cathodic protection to forensic electrical engineering often means we at Dreiym have to occasionally provide expert testimony. Whether the court admits that testimony depends on the standard it applies: Frye vs. Daubert.
Key takeaways
- Whether a court admits expert testimony depends on the standard it applies: Frye or Daubert.
- The Frye standard comes from Frye v. United States in 1923 and admits scientific evidence only when its methods are generally accepted in the field.
- The Daubert standard comes from a 1993 Supreme Court case and gives judges more room to decide admissibility.
- Under Daubert, a judge may ask whether a method has been tested and whether it has been through peer review and publication.
- In federal court, Federal Rule of Evidence 702 governs the admissibility of expert testimony.
See how this worked on a real job: Underground Cable Failures at an Energy Site, Hawaii
Legal challenges about how a fire began at an industrial complex or whether or not a building had proper arc flash protection are crucial to assigning financial responsibility for repairs and compensation. We help uncover those truths by analyzing the root cause of so many incidents. We also help juries, legal entities, and businesses better understand what should have been in place to prevent such damage.
The trick is that there are different admissibility standards for deciding whether a forensic engineer’s findings can be presented at all. Those standards shape current litigation and the way firms like ours practice. The two that matter most are Frye and Daubert. Where a court comes down on Frye vs. Daubert decides how an engineer’s findings reach the jury.
A Quick History of Daubert vs. Frye
The primary goal of Daubert and Frye is to provide a framework for evaluating expert testimony. Courts want to ensure they are receiving proper evidentiary information that can be used to make decisions and sway juries.
Before 1923, courts looked more at an expert witness’s credentials and relevant experience in the field. For example, a medical provider might testify about a malpractice suit. The court would consider where they received training, their area of specialty, and how many years they’ve practiced.
Attorneys still bring those points up. The Frye standard didn’t arrive until 1923, though, and the Daubert standard not until 1993. Neither one has stood still since. Both come from case law, but in federal court, Federal Rule of Evidence 702 governs admissibility. An amendment in 2000 codified Daubert and Kumho Tire in that rule. Another amendment took effect December 1, 2023. States change course too (Florida moved from Frye to Daubert in 2019). So the governing test needs confirming for each jurisdiction at the start of every engagement.
Without a working knowledge of both standards, forensic engineers would have a hard time finding their way through the legal system. Knowing them helps us give the court findings that are scientifically accurate and legally admissible.

Background on Frye and Daubert Standards
The Frye Standard
Frye standard comes from a 1923 case known as Frye v. United States. It is here the courts first established that scientific evidence is only admissible as long as the methodologies utilized or underlying principles are “generally accepted” by industry/scientific communities. You can think of a “Frye Challenge” as someone stating the concept is not “generally accepted.”
Put another way, a consensus must accept the evidential force of the methods used. It is like a peer-reviewed study in which everyone reading the information presented in a journal agrees that it “carries weight.”
The upside is you get measurable techniques for presenting information to a court. The downside is if you have a new method for testing or providing data, you will face legal challenges. This is why the Frye Standard wasn’t really accepted until the 1970s and began facing criticisms of being too vague in the 1980s.
There are a number of states that rely on the Frye Standard due to their trust in precedent and tradition. In other areas, courts rely more on the Daubert Standard.
The Daubert Standard
Unlike the Frye Standard, which relies on consensus, the Daubert Standard gives judges more “wiggle room” to decide admissibility. Daubert comes from a 1993 Supreme Court case of Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc. During this case, justices introduced a new framework for expert testimony in federal courts. It emphasizes scientific rigor and judicial oversight.
Daubert was later expanded in 1997 via General Electric Co v. Joiner, 522 U.S. 136, finding that “conclusion and methodology are not entirely distinct from another.” The idea is to give judges a “gatekeeper” role so they can evaluate if an expert’s methodology is reliable and relevant to the case at hand.
Factors a Judge May Consider
The Court in Daubert named several factors a judge may consider, and the list isn’t closed. The judge can ask whether the method is testable and whether anyone has tested it. The judge can also ask whether it has been through peer review and publication. Its known or potential rate of error counts. So do the existence and maintenance of standards controlling its operation. So does how widely the relevant scientific community accepts it. Judges should apply these factors flexibly. Kumho Tire confirms that no single factor is mandatory. It also confirms that the trial court decides which ones are useful for the particular technique at issue.
- Can the methodology being presented be tested (in a reliable way)?
- Have the methods presented or testimony procedures been subject to peer review or scrutiny?
- Is there some measurable form of error in the methodologies?
- Do the methods being used have standards and controls?
- Is the technique accepted within the given industry or scientific industry?
What is beneficial about the Daubert Standard is you get a lot more flexibility. It allows forensic engineering firms to introduce novel or innovative techniques, as long as they meet those outlined parameters. We can present exhaustive documentation and processes that support our findings and their admissibility.
However, it is also just as common to receive a “Daubert Challenge.” Here, the opposing counsel will question the admissibility of the testimony, and it is up to the expert to present and validate the methods used. The clearer the science (relayed in an accepted form of communication), the likelier it is to hold up in court.
Federal courts and most states now rely on the Daubert Standard. It is a good mix of both science and peer-reviewed input.

Key Differences
Whenever a team like ours has to present expert testimony, we always look at the state or federal history. We need to know which standard the court is likely to apply. Knowing this difference is crucial. Frye relies more on a “general acceptance” of methods. Daubert evaluates the reliability and relevance of those methods, subject to a judge’s discretion.
Frye can be a little restrictive in a situation outside the normal procedures of forensic engineering. The same is true when you have to “cross-pollinate” some procedures from other sciences to explain a result. Daubert tends to provide more opportunities for innovative methods on the cutting edge of science. Those methods still need clear documentation and peer review backing.
You’ll also see them called the Frye test and the Daubert test. Those are other names for the same standards, and the table below puts the two side by side.
| Frye Standard | Daubert Standard | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Frye v. United States (D.C. Cir. 1923) | Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (U.S. Supreme Court, 1993) |
| Core test | General acceptance in the relevant scientific community | Reliability and relevance of the methodology |
| Who decides | The relevant scientific community, in effect | The trial judge, acting as gatekeeper |
| Factors weighed | One: general acceptance | Five non-exclusive factors: testability, peer review, error rate, standards and controls, general acceptance |
| Scope | Novel scientific evidence in most Frye states | All expert testimony, technical and scientific (Kumho Tire, 1999) |
| Where it applies | A shrinking minority of states | Federal courts and most states, through Rule 702 |
| New or novel methods | Harder to admit until the field adopts them | Admissible when the methodology is shown to be reliable |
A good example of the difference between Frye and Daubert is AI (artificial intelligence). Advanced computer simulations using AI for forensic engineering still face challenges. It can be difficult to present all the information in an unbiased way for a judge to see. That assumes they will use the equipment provided for such a presentation.
How Federal and State Courts Differ
Courts across the United States don’t agree on one standard for expert testimony from forensic engineers like us at Dreiym Engineering. Federal courts are simpler. They rely on the Supreme Court’s decision in Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc. as precedent, along with Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael in 1999.
When you think of testifying to federal courts, it comes down to the reliability of the standards presented. While Daubert is more flexible, you really must demonstrate that any given forensic methodologies rest on sound scientific principles. Remember that under a Daubert challenge, the judge acts as the gatekeeper. So you have the communication issue of explaining such a method in terms courts will understand.
As for state-by-state variability in Frye vs. Daubert, it’s tough to give one standard. For instance, Dreiym Engineering is based in Texas. We serve clients all over the globe. Still, we do most of our testifying in courts using the Rule of Evidence 702 and a Modified Daubert. However, suppose we were to provide evidence up north in Washington state. We would still need the Rule of Evidence 702, but through the lens of the Frye Standard.
Which States Use the Frye Standard vs. the Daubert Standard?
Every federal court applies the Daubert standard through Federal Rule of Evidence 702. The large majority of states now follow Daubert or something close to it. As of 2026, the states still using Frye or a test built on it include:
- California (the Kelly-Frye rule for novel scientific techniques, plus broader gatekeeping duties for judges since 2012)
- Illinois
- Minnesota (the Frye-Mack standard for novel scientific evidence)
- New York
- Pennsylvania
- Washington
The trend has been toward Daubert. The District of Columbia, where the court decided Frye, adopted Daubert in 2016. New Jersey adopted the Daubert factors for civil cases in 2018, Florida switched in 2019, and Maryland followed in 2020. Several states use hybrid tests or admissibility rules of their own. Labeling a state Frye or Daubert only gets you started. At the start of every forensic engagement, we confirm the governing standard with counsel.
What Is Federal Rule of Evidence 702?
The Rule of Evidence 702 faces frequent challenges in courts. In the simplest terms, it means any expert with special knowledge in a field (expertise) may testify. The purpose is to help a jury understand complicated facts in a case. That knowledge must be reliable and relevant and subject to a gatekeeper judge.
Most of the information in this rule comes from the Daubert Standard. Think of it as proving expert qualifications of the testimony and providing direct relevance to the facts of the case. It also means offering a method based on reliable scientific principles.
The key item to remember is the Rule of Evidence 702 cannot be based on personal beliefs or opinions. If an expert witness were to say, “The world is flat because I’m an astronaut and geologist,” but provide no relevant, proven, and reliable methodologies to such a statement, it would likely be thrown out of court as inadmissible.
An amendment that took effect December 1, 2023, spelled out two things in Rule 702. The party offering the expert has to show it’s more likely than not that the rule’s reliability requirements are met. And the expert’s opinion has to reflect a reliable application of their methods to the facts of the case. For a forensic engineer, that means the report has to show the work behind the conclusion. Stating the conclusion isn’t enough.
Related service
Expert reports for attorneys, insurers and owners. Consulting-only retentions are accepted.
Implications for Forensic Engineering Practice
Preparing for Testimony
As you can imagine, forensic engineers have to be prepared for either a Daubert challenge or a Frye challenge. To do this, they must spend a lot of time and energy preparing for the testimony. Experts need to provide technical information, reliable methodologies, and meet the legal criteria of the jurisdiction, all without sacrificing simplified language that a jury will absorb.
It helps to ensure the testimony provided demonstrates testable, peer-reviewed information with a known error rate. The scientific community should also widely accept that information. The more forensic engineers maintain this standard, the better the outcome. Such meticulous attention reduces the risk of exclusionary data. That data might shift responsibility or blame in cases ranging from insurance fraud to arson.
Challenges Faced
Forensic Engineers must also prepare for challenges. The first set of challenges will be jurisdictional. Suppose an expert witness prepares for the Frye Standard in an area that actually uses the Daubert Standard. The opposing counsel will then attempt to toss the testimony.
Next will be the details of the analysis. Engineers must be adaptable to live testimony adjustments and balance technical complexity with courtroom communication. Being the smartest kid in the room is only helpful if you also can provide complex information in a way that doesn’t overwhelm the rest of the people involved. In some ways, you have to be both an expert witness and an information guide willing to teach while you testify.
Finally, forensic engineers have to deal with frequent Daubert challenges. These seek to discredit any testimony by questioning the underlying validity of the techniques, methodologies, or processes involved. That can be a massive hurdle to leap if the court or jury has no experience with the given topic or case at hand.
The best way to prevent any of these challenges from “derailing” a case is by being well-prepared with legal requirements and current industry standards so your expertise shines through in a testimony.
Opportunities for Improvement
Change is inevitable. It is as regular as death and taxes. The more legal case diversity happens, the greater the need for evolving standards in expert testimony. Forensic engineers have the opportunity to be at the forefront of this need.
With advanced technologies uncovering new methods like AI, drones, and component testing, we will likely see Daubert challenges increase. That is why experts like ours at Dreiym Engineering continue to collaborate within the industry. We attend the latest conferences, trade shows, and receive ongoing training to ensure our hard-earned reputation as experts in our industry remains undeniable.
Clients rely on our expertise to get the truth about so many situations. We take this seriously and are fully committed to meeting and improving any standards necessary so that we may present clear evidence-backed testimony.
How the Standards Play Out in Practice
Case law on Frye and Daubert is fairly extensive. It seems like every industrial accident or mechanical lawsuit ends with some form of expert testimony that is challenged. The two scenarios below are hypothetical composites rather than actual cases. They show how each standard handles that kind of challenge.
Example 1: A Frye Jurisdiction Case
Let’s consider the Frye Standard first. We are in a state that uses such a standard for testimony. A forensic engineer is presenting information on a structural failure lawsuit involving a collapsed highway bridge. Using a novel computer simulation, the engineer demonstrates how material fatigue over time directly contributed to the collapse.
Established analyses like finite element and fatigue modeling usually pass the general acceptance test in a Frye jurisdiction. Their principles and methods have a long publication record and wide use. A Frye challenge comes when the technique is genuinely new. Say our engineer pairs the standard fatigue analysis with an immersive virtual-reality re-enactment so jurors can “experience” the collapse. Opposing counsel moves to exclude it. Their argument is that the field hasn’t generally adopted the method, and that it may not fairly represent the analysis underneath.
In this scenario, the court excludes the virtual-reality presentation but still admits the conventional fatigue analysis. So in a Frye state, everything in the testimony, down to how the findings are presented, should rest on generally accepted methods. Otherwise critical information may never reach the jury.
Example 2: A Daubert Jurisdiction Case
Now, let’s flip over to a federal court where the Daubert Standard has wide acceptance. Here, our forensic engineer presents information about a recent pipeline explosion. Evidence about advanced soil corrosion modeling that identifies a previously undetected cause of the failure is provided.
As expected, the opposing counsel issues a Daubert challenge. But the engineer is well prepared. The engineer demonstrates that the modeling technique methodology is testable, peer-reviewed, and has a low documented error rate. With the judge as the gatekeeper, the court rules the testimony admissible. It then holds the responsible parties liable for damages.
Both examples show how hard it can be, in cases with this much at stake, to present findings that hold up scientifically and are still easy to follow. Anyone giving expert testimony has to prepare well and know which standard applies. If you need that kind of evidence, an experienced team like ours at Dreiym Engineering is your best bet.
The Role of the Judge as a Gatekeeper
One of the aspects of the Daubert Standard is worth focusing on a little closer. That would be the idea of judges serving as gatekeepers.
What Happens at a Daubert Hearing?
Opposing counsel finds the expert testimony during discovery and files a Daubert challenge. The judge then looks at whether the evidence rests on accepted scientific principles and meets the criteria behind them. Most of the time, that review happens at a pretrial hearing.
After that, the judge rules on whether the testimony meets the threshold for admissibility. The ruling matters to the case at hand, and it also sets a precedent for future cases. The precedent is the part we want to emphasize.
Daubert provides a certain level of flexibility. Still, a forensic engineering firm has a massive responsibility to adhere to industry-accepted ideals and standards when presenting new methodologies. If courts allow a lower standard of evidence, we as a society run the risk of not finding the truth.
The point is that you want to hire an engineering firm with the experience to present expert testimony, but also the awareness of a judge’s or jurisdiction’s history when it relates to scientific inquiry and methodology.

Frequently Asked Questions About Frye vs. Daubert
How are the Frye and Daubert standards alike and different?
Both keep unreliable expert evidence away from the jury, and both ask whether the scientific community stands behind the method. Under Frye, general acceptance by the relevant field is the whole test, so the field in effect makes the call. Under Daubert, the judge does, weighing acceptance as one of several reliability factors.
What is a Daubert motion?
A Daubert motion is a pretrial request for the judge to exclude the other side’s expert testimony as unreliable or irrelevant. If the court holds a hearing on it, the judge examines the expert’s qualifications and methodology before the trial ever starts. The judge also examines how the expert applied that methodology to the facts.
What are the five Daubert factors?
The Court in Daubert named testability, peer review and publication, the known or potential error rate, the existence of standards controlling the technique, and general acceptance in the relevant scientific community. No single factor is required, and the judge decides which ones fit the technique at issue.
Which states still use the Frye standard?
As of 2026, the states still using Frye or a version of it are California, Illinois, Minnesota, New York, Pennsylvania, and Washington, each with its own variations. Federal courts and the other states apply the Daubert standard or a modified version of it.
Does the standard change how a forensic engineer works?
The investigation itself shouldn’t change. We document methods, error rates, and the standards applied the same way on every matter. What changes is how the expert prepares to testify. In a Frye state, the focus is on how widely the method is accepted and published. In a Daubert court, the expert has to be ready to defend reliability one factor at a time.
Honest Testimony Under Either Standard
Any forensic engineering firm that gives expert testimony has to deal with Frye vs. Daubert and with how each standard applies. Its experts have to meet whichever standard the jurisdiction uses, with the scientific rigor the case calls for.
Don’t forget there are ethical considerations. Experts may feel pressure from either defending or prosecuting attorneys to give testimony that sways a jury one way or the other. The integrity of a forensic engineering firm must be without question. That requires a formal commitment to seeking the truth through evidence-based processes. Those processes should be reliable, tested, and easy to communicate to those without such expertise.
A lot rides on any case that goes in front of a judge. Insurance companies know how much expert testimony can sway the outcome. So do the law firms and businesses involved, and even governments. Getting through a Daubert challenge or a Frye challenge takes professionally prepared evidence and careful documentation, from people who care about getting the science right.
We provide reliable, scientifically defensible evidence, and we prepare it to stand up to scrutiny under either the Frye or the Daubert standard. Dreiym Engineering PLLC has provided electrical, corrosion and forensic engineering services since 2014. Our licensed professional engineers have active and past licensure in multiple states and more than 30 years of combined experience. If you need expert testimony or civil investigation support, contact our professional team.