Licensed Professional Engineers |
Search/

Request a free quote

Fire Investigation

Lithium-Ion Battery Fire Investigation: What It Can and Can’t Determine

How engineers investigate e-bike, scooter, power tool and laptop battery fires: cause or victim, scene evidence, X-ray, limits, and records that help.

cell phone on firecell phone on fire
Contents
  1. Why Battery Fires Are Different
  2. Where Lithium-Ion Battery Fires Start
  3. Cause or Victim?
  4. At the Scene
  5. In the Lab
  6. What an Investigation Can’t Always Determine
  7. Records That Help
  8. Frequently Asked Questions
  9. How Dreiym Engineering Can Help

A lithium-ion battery fire investigation has to answer two questions: did the fire start at the battery, and if it did, why. Investigators first establish the area of origin from the fire patterns, the electrical system and witness accounts, then examine the battery pack, its cells, the battery management system (BMS) and the charger to tell a battery that failed first from one that was destroyed by a fire that started somewhere else. Many of these questions can be answered. Some can’t, especially when the cells that would show how the failure began have burned away or been thrown across the room.

Key takeaways

  1. A lithium-ion battery fire investigation asks two questions: did the fire start at the battery, and if so, why.
  2. Investigators first establish the area of origin from the fire patterns, the electrical system and witness accounts, then examine the pack and its cells.
  3. Any lithium-ion battery in a fire will usually go into thermal runaway, whether it started the fire or not.
  4. Battery evidence is fragile and can be dangerous, and lab work starts with non-destructive steps under a protocol the parties have seen.
  5. An investigation cannot always determine why a battery failed.

This article is about consumer packs: e-bikes, e-scooters and other micromobility products, power tool batteries, laptops and similar devices. For larger systems, see our pages on electric vehicle fire investigations and residential energy storage system fire investigations.

Why Battery Fires Are Different

A lithium-ion cell stores a lot of energy in a small space, and its electrolyte is flammable. When a cell is damaged or pushed outside its safe operating range, an internal short circuit can heat it faster than it can shed the heat. The result is thermal runaway: a self-heating reaction that vents flammable gases, builds pressure, and can rupture the cell and throw out flame, hot gas and molten material. The heat from one cell can drive its neighbors into thermal runaway, so a pack can fail cell by cell over seconds or minutes.

That makes these fires fast. In full-scale experiments by UL®’s Fire Safety Research Institute (FSRI), working with the Fire Department of the City of New York, an overcharged e-scooter in a closed bedroom broke the bedroom windows about 12 seconds after the first signs of smoke, and the room reached flashover within 30 seconds of the window failure.

The Consumer Product Safety Commission’s June 2026 proposed rule for micromobility batteries counted 227 incidents from 2019 through 2023, with 39 deaths and 181 injuries. More than half of the incidents, 120, happened while the product was plugged in and charging. Others involved aftermarket batteries or chargers, products stored or resting, batteries that had been removed or replaced, water exposure and homemade packs.

Where Lithium-Ion Battery Fires Start

NFPA® lists physical damage, electrical damage such as overcharging or charging equipment not designed for the battery, exposure to extreme temperatures, and product defects among the reasons lithium-ion batteries catch fire. In an investigation those become specific hypotheses, each of which leaves different evidence:

Failure pathTypical examplesWhat investigators look for
Internal cell defectContamination or a manufacturing flaw that leads to an internal shortWhich cell failed first, its internal condition, the cell maker and lot, recalls
Overcharge or charging faultIncompatible or aftermarket charger, failed charge control or BMSThe charger’s rating and markings, the BMS board, whether the product was charging
External short circuitDamaged connectors or wiring, loose cells carried with metal objectsConnector pins, wiring insulation, debris inside the pack
Physical damageDrops, crushing, punctures, a hard impact on a bike or toolDents or cracks in the housing and cells, damage history
Heat, cold and waterStorage near heat, charging below freezing, submersionWhere it was stored and charged, weather, water exposure
ModificationHomemade packs, conversion kits, replaced cellsNon-original cells, solder repairs, tape, missing protection
Diagram of a receptacle, a charger and a battery pack with numbered places a fire can start: 1 an internal defect in one cell, 2 an overcharge or charging fault in the charger or the battery management system, 3 an external short at the connector or wiring, 4 physical damage to the pack, 5 heat, cold or water, and 6 modification, shown as a mismatched cell held with tape. A note says the receptacle and branch circuit are examined too.
Figure 1. Where a lithium-ion battery fire can start in a consumer device: the cells, the battery management system, the connectors and wiring, the charger, and conditions outside the pack.

The product type shapes which paths are most likely. E-bikes and scooters carry large packs that are charged often, sometimes with replacement chargers or batteries, and are exposed to weather and impacts. Power tool packs are removed and recharged constantly and get dropped on job sites. Laptops and phones use thin cells that can swell when they degrade or are damaged.

Cause or Victim?

Any lithium-ion battery in a fire will usually end up in thermal runaway, whether it started the fire or not. External heat alone can do it: in the same FSRI work, a heater applied to the outside of five cells drove a whole e-scooter pack into thermal runaway. A burned pack with ejected cells is not, by itself, evidence that the battery caused the fire.

That’s why the investigation starts with the room, not the battery. Following NFPA® 921’s scientific method, the investigator establishes the area of origin from fire patterns, arc mapping of the building’s branch circuits, the sequence of events and witness accounts, and only then tests hypotheses about the cause, including the battery and every other competent ignition source in the area of origin.

QuestionWhat can help answer itLimits
Was the battery in the area of origin?Fire patterns, arc mapping, witness accounts, photos and videoA fast fire can produce patterns that are hard to read
Was it charging or in use?Charger and cord found at the device, receptacle and power strip condition, witness accountsA charger plugged in doesn’t prove it was charging
Were there early warning signs?Reports of popping, hissing, smoke or swelling, smoke alarm timingWitness memory after a fire is imperfect
Did a cell fail from the inside?Comparing the internal condition of cells, X-ray, disassemblyThe first cell may be consumed or missing
Was the charger or BMS at fault?Examination of the charger and BMS board, comparison with exemplarsElectronics are often destroyed
Was the product modified or damaged?Non-original parts, repairs, purchase and repair recordsRecords may not exist
Flow chart: establish the area of origin at the scene. If the battery was not in the area of origin, treat it as a victim and test the other ignition sources. If it was, test every hypothesis, including internal cell failure, a charger or BMS fault, an external short, physical damage, heat, cold or water, and modification, then examine it in the lab, X-ray first. Outcomes: the battery caused the fire with the mechanism identified, the battery caused the fire with the mechanism undetermined, or the cause is undetermined.
Figure 2. How an investigation reaches a conclusion: the area of origin comes first, then hypotheses about the battery and every other ignition source are tested against the evidence, and the cause is classified or left undetermined.

Related service

Fire & Explosion

Origin and cause, evidence and lab examination

Submit an assignment

At the Scene

Battery evidence is fragile and can be dangerous. Damaged cells can go back into thermal runaway hours or days later, and a pack can hold stranded energy even when it looks burned out. At the scene, the investigator:

  • Documents before moving anything, including where each ejected cell, cell fragment and piece of the pack landed. Cells can be thrown several feet, and their positions help reconstruct the event.
  • Collects every cell and fragment that can be found, along with the pack housing, the BMS board, connectors and wiring.
  • Collects the charger, its cord and what it was plugged into, including the receptacle, the power strip or extension cord, and the branch circuit, so the electrical supply can be examined too.
  • Collects exemplars and documentation where possible: an identical product, its charger, the manual and the packaging.
  • Packages batteries separately in non-combustible containers, stores them away from other evidence, and never charges or powers them.

Interested parties, such as the manufacturer, the retailer and the importer, should get notice before evidence is removed or altered. Our fire scene evidence preservation checklist covers notice, joint scene examinations and chain of custody in detail.

In the Lab

Lab work follows the same order as any fire evidence examination: non-destructive steps first, under a protocol the interested parties have seen.

  1. Visual examination and photography of the pack, cells and charger as received
  2. Real-time X-ray of the pack and cells before anything is opened, to see cell positions, internal structure, connections and debris without disturbing them
  3. Microscopic examination of cell tabs, welds, connector pins and the BMS board
  4. Examination of the charger, its rating and markings, and whether it matches what the product requires
  5. Step-by-step disassembly, photographed at each step, with cells identified and mapped to their positions in the pack
  6. Comparison with exemplars, which shows what the undamaged design looks like and whether parts were replaced

Our X-ray work in this kind of examination is described on our engineering X-ray services page.

What an Investigation Can’t Always Determine

Honest reports say what the evidence can’t show. Common limits:

  • The first cell may be gone. If the initiating cell burned away, vented its contents or was lost in the debris, the internal evidence of how the failure began may not survive.
  • The most damaged cell isn’t necessarily the first. Cells deep in a pack can see more heat than the one that started the failure.
  • Electronics may be destroyed. A burned BMS board or charger may not show whether it failed.
  • A defect may be impossible to confirm from the remains, even when the battery clearly was the origin. The cause can then be identified as the battery while the failure mechanism stays open.
  • Some causes stay undetermined. NFPA® 921 allows a cause to be classified as undetermined when the evidence doesn’t support one hypothesis over the others. That is a legitimate result, not a failed investigation.

Records That Help

Records collected early often fill the gaps the debris leaves:

  • Purchase records: where and when it was bought, the model, serial number and listing marks. Micromobility products are evaluated to standards such as UL® 2849 for e-bike electrical systems, UL® 2272 for personal e-mobility devices and UL® 2271 for light electric vehicle batteries.
  • The charger in use, and whether it was the original or a replacement.
  • Charging habits: where and when it was charged, and for how long.
  • Damage and repair history: drops, crashes, water exposure, repairs, replacement batteries and conversion kits.
  • Recall status. CPSC lists recalls of batteries and battery-powered products. A recall is useful context, but it isn’t proof that the recalled defect caused this fire.
  • Photos and video of the product before the fire, and any app or BMS data the product kept.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you tell whether a battery caused the fire if it burned completely?

Often, yes, at the level of origin: fire patterns, arc mapping and witness accounts can show that the fire started at the battery even when little of it is left. What may not survive is the evidence of why the battery failed.

Should we keep the charger?

Yes. The charger, its cord, and the receptacle or power strip it was plugged into are part of the evidence. Overcharging and incompatible chargers are among the causes investigators test.

Does a recall prove the battery was defective?

No. A recall shows that a product line had a problem. The investigation still has to show that this product was in the area of origin and that the failure is consistent with the recalled defect.

Do you investigate electric vehicle and home battery fires too?

Yes. See our electric vehicle fire investigation and residential energy storage system fire investigation pages.

Can we retain an engineer as a consulting expert only?

Yes. Counsel often retains an engineer first as a consulting, non-testifying expert to evaluate a battery fire claim. We accept consulting-only retentions.

How Dreiym Engineering Can Help

We investigate fire origin and cause and appliance and product failures, with scene inspections as soon as possible after we’re retained. Brian J. Brackensick, M.S., P.E. and Stepan V. Eero, M.S., P.E. both hold the NAFI CFEI® and CVFI certifications. Our engineering lab in Coldspring, Texas has in-house real-time X-ray, a Nordson® Dage® Quadra® 3, for parts up to 20 x 17.5 in and 11 lb at up to 7,500x magnification, and a microscope with an 18 MP camera, and evidence storage is video-monitored. We accept consulting-only retentions, and reports are PE-stamped where required. For more on the lab, see our post on X-ray inspections in forensics. To start an assignment, use our forensic assignment form. Contact us or call (866) 621-6920 for a free quote. We typically respond within one business day.

Have a loss to investigate?

We typically respond within one business day.

Submit an assignmentor call (866) 621-6920