Licensed Professional Engineers |
Search/

Request a free quote

Free tool screening estimate

Transformer DGA Calculator

Screens dissolved gas results for a mineral oil transformer: IEEE® C57.104-2019 DGA status from levels, changes and rates, and the Duval Triangle 1 zone, with a PDF report.

Tool referenceDE-TOOL-11171

Method
IEEE® C57.104-2019 DGA status; Duval Triangle 1
Inputs
Up to 20 samples, nine gases, age
Output
DGA status 1 to 3, Duval zone, PDF report

Dissolved gas analysis (DGA) of transformer oil is the most common way to watch a transformer for internal faults. This workbench applies the IEEE® C57.104-2019 status procedure to every sample you enter, shows how the status changed over time and, when the gas levels call for it, identifies the likely fault type with the Duval methods in the guide. The calculation runs on our server; the values you enter are not stored.

Screening estimate only. Do not rely on these results for any decision about a transformer until Dreiym Engineering has reviewed the full test history under a written engagement.

Request a review

Next steps

Ask an expert

Brian J. Brackensick, M.S., P.E.

Electrical & Corrosion Engineer

Dreiym Engineering

(866) 621-6920

Request a review

We typically respond within one business day.

View his profile

When to call an engineer

A screening estimate, not a diagnosis. A qualified engineer should review the full test history before anyone acts on it.

Related service

Electrical & Power

Power system studies, testing and equipment reviews, transformers included.

Standards used

IEEE® Std C57.104-2019

Guide for the interpretation of gases generated in mineral oil-immersed transformers: DGA status and Duval Triangle 1.

Cite or share this tool

Dreiym Engineering. Transformer DGA calculator. Method: IEEE® Std C57.104-2019 DGA status and Duval Triangle 1. https://www.dreiym.com/transformer-dga-calculator/

Instructors and shops are welcome to link to this tool or put its address on a handout. It is free, needs no sign-up and works on a phone.

How to use the workbench

  1. Enter your samples. Type them in the sheet, paste rows from a spreadsheet, upload the Excel® template, or pick one of the synthetic examples to see how the tool works.
  2. Describe the transformer. Give its age if you know it, the insulating liquid and the compartment the oil came from.
  3. Pass the quick check and get the result. After the first result, every valid change you make is recalculated; while a field is invalid the results stay closed.
  4. Read the result. The status, the summary in plain words, the next-sample guidance and the fault type, then download the PDF report if you need one.

What the three DGA statuses mean

  • Status 1. Gas levels, changes and rates are all below the typical values: probably normal by the statistics of the guide. Routine sampling continues.
  • Status 2. A gas level, a change or a rate reached its typical value: possibly suspicious, worth a closer look and more frequent sampling.
  • Status 3. A gas level is above its 95th percentile value, or a multi-point rate is above its typical value: probably suspicious, with closer surveillance and a review recommended.

History, snapshots and next steps

The status strip shows the status the calculator would have given at each sample date, using only that sample and the earlier ones. Pick a date in the strip or the slider to see the whole result as of that day. The escalation table lists each change of status with the gases that drove it, and the summary says when Status 2 or Status 3 was first reached.

The next-sample guidance follows the guide: routine sampling under your own policy at Status 1, a confirmation sample within a month when the status comes only from a change or a rate, more frequent sampling at Status 2 and closer surveillance at Status 3. When a rate is available, the projection says which gas would reach the level of the next status within five years if the current rate continued. It is a straight line from your own data, not a forecast.

Fault type: the Duval methods

Duval Triangle 1, in the main text of the guide, uses the relative amounts of methane, ethylene and acetylene to suggest a fault type: partial discharges, low or high energy discharges, thermal faults below 300 °C, from 300 to 700 °C and above 700 °C, or a mixture. Duval Triangles 4 and 5 and Duval Pentagons 1 and 2, from informative Annex D, refine it, each only under the conditions the annex gives. The guide recommends fault identification only when at least one gas is at or above its 90th percentile value, so below that the figures stay behind a switch.

When the fault type is shown, the workbench also lists cross-checks from other methods described in the guide, such as the Rogers ratios, the key gas reading and the carbon oxide ratio, and says whether each agrees with Duval Triangle 1. Point at or tap any zone to read what it means.

Liquid and compartment

The IEEE® C57.104 status method covers mineral oil in a main tank that does not share oil or gas with a load tap changer. For a load tap changer compartment, a main tank that shares oil with one, or a liquid other than mineral oil, the workbench gives no status and shows the samples and trends only. IEEE® C57.155 covers natural and synthetic esters and IEEE® C57.146 covers silicone.

What the workbench does not cover

Screening estimate only. Do not rely on these results for any decision about a transformer until Dreiym Engineering has reviewed the full test history under a written engagement.

Bushings and cables have their own gas analysis practices. If you need those, or a review of a transformer result, contact Dreiym Engineering: the card after the results reaches Brian J. Brackensick, M.S., P.E.

Method and sources

  1. IEEE® Std C57.104-2019, IEEE® Guide for the Interpretation of Gases Generated in Mineral Oil-Immersed Transformers: DGA status procedure, Tables 1 to 4, Duval Triangle 1 (Table 6) and Annex D.
  2. M. Duval and L. Lamarre, The Duval Pentagon: a new complementary tool for the interpretation of dissolved gas analysis in transformers, IEEE® Electrical Insulation Magazine, vol. 30, no. 6, 2014.

For a longer walk-through of reading and trending a DGA report, and the standards that relate to it, see Transformer Dissolved Gas Analysis: How to Read and Trend a DGA Report.

When you use the workbench, the values you enter are sent to our calculation server to compute the result and, if you ask, the PDF. They are not stored or logged. The optional label is printed on the PDF only.

Frequently asked questions

What is a normal DGA result for a transformer?

IEEE® C57.104-2019 calls a result probably normal (Status 1) when every gas is below the 90th percentile value for the transformer’s O2/N2 ratio and age, the change since the previous sample is below the typical change, and any multi-point rate is below the typical rate. The values themselves are in the standard.

Why does the O2/N2 ratio matter?

The guide gives separate values for an O2/N2 ratio at or below 0.2 and above 0.2, because the oxygen in the oil reflects how the transformer is sealed and affects how gases build up. When the ratio is not available, the values for a ratio above 0.2 are used, as the guide says.

When are the Duval figures shown?

Only when a gas is at or above its 90th percentile value, as the guide recommends. A triangle always names a zone, even for a healthy transformer, and at very low levels the laboratory uncertainty can move the point between zones, so a zone on its own is not a diagnosis.

Is the result a diagnosis?

No. It is a screening estimate from the published methods. Results depend on how the oil was sampled, handled and tested. A qualified engineer should review the full test history, the transformer’s design and its operating record before anyone acts on it.

Are the values I enter stored?

No. They are sent to our calculation server to compute the result and, if you ask, the PDF, and are not stored or logged. The optional label is printed on the PDF only.

Need more than a screening estimate?

We typically respond within one business day.

Request a free quoteor call (866) 621-6920