Free tool screening estimate
Soil Corrosivity Calculator: 10-Point Score and Resistivity Scales
Scores soil test results with the 10-point evaluation for ductile iron pipe and places the resistivity on five published scales side by side.
Tool referenceDE-TOOL-10731
- Method
- 10-point system as published by DIPRA® (2017) and EPRI® (Table 9-3)
- Factors
- Resistivity, pH, redox, sulfides, moisture
- Output
- Points, total and resistivity on five scales
This soil corrosivity calculator scores soil test results with the 10-point evaluation for ductile iron pipe and shows the soil resistivity on five published scales side by side. In one of DIPRA®’s published case histories, from Fayetteville, Arkansas, soil of 1,600 Ω·cm with pH 6.8, a redox potential of −100 mV, positive sulfides and poor drainage scores 21.5 points; ten points or more rates a soil corrosive to ductile iron pipe.
Soil corrosivity calculator: 10-point score and resistivity scales
Enter the soil test results you have. The calculator scores them with the 10-point soil test evaluation for ductile iron pipe, factor by factor, and places the resistivity on five published scales side by side, so you can see where they disagree. Leave a field empty if that test was not done.
The calculator needs JavaScript®. The point table and the resistivity scales are on this page.
Quick start Fills in the form. Change anything after.
Result
21.5 points: corrosive to ductile iron pipe by the 10-point system
Points: resistivity 8, pH 3, redox 5, sulfides 3.5, moisture 2. Total 21.5.
1,600 Ω·cm on the five published scales is in the table below. The scales draw their bands at different values, so the same soil gets a different class on each.
The score does not cover stray current. DIPRA® adds that stray direct current and experience with nearby underground structures should also be considered.
- Points
- 21.5
- Most possible
- 21.5
- Resistivity, Ω·cm
- 1,600
A score is a screening step, not a design. It does not measure stray current or microbiological corrosion, and the method itself is debated. See soil corrosivity testing, or ask an engineer.
This resistivity on five published scales
| Scale and source | Bands, Ω·cm | Your soil |
|---|---|---|
| 10-point system, ANSI®/AWWA C105/A21.5-18 points (DIPRA® 2017; EPRI® 3002005294 Table 9-3) | Below 1,500: 10; 1,500 to 1,800: 8; to 2,100: 5; to 2,500: 2; to 3,000: 1; above 3,000: 0 | 8 points |
| Same table, 1993 edition bands (EPRI® correction notice, 2025) | Below 700: 10; 700 to 1,000: 8; to 1,200: 5; to 1,500: 2; to 2,000: 1; above 2,000: 0 | 1 point |
| UFC 3-570-06 (2019), Table 4-1 | 0 to 500 severely; 500 to 999 very; 1,000 to 2,999 corrosive; 3,000 to 9,999 moderately; 10,000 to 25,000 slightly; above 25,000 relatively less corrosive | Corrosive |
| EPRI® 3002005294 (2015), Table 2-1, carbon steel | Below 500 extremely; 500 to 1,000 very; 1,000 to 10,000 corrosive; 10,000 to 20,000 moderately; above 20,000 progressively less corrosive | Corrosive |
| Reclamation TM 8540-2024-13, Table 1 (October 2025 draft for review) | 500 or less: 25; to 2,000: 20; to 5,000: 15; to 10,000: 10; above 10,000: 0 | 20 points |
Full results and steps
| Factor | Value | Points |
|---|---|---|
| resistivity | 1,600 Ω·cm | 8 / 10 |
| pH | 6.8 | 3 / 5 |
| redox | −100 mV | 5 / 5 |
| sulfides | Positive | 3.5 / 3.5 |
| moisture | Poor drainage, continuously wet | 2 / 2 |
| Total | 21.5 |
- Each factor is scored from the point table (DIPRA® 2017, page 7; EPRI® 3002005294 Table 9-3).
- pH 6.5 to 7.5 scores 3 instead of 0 when sulfides are present and redox is below 100 mV or negative.
- Total 21.5 points; with the missing tests at their highest, 21.5. Ten points or more: corrosive to ductile iron pipe.
Planning a pipeline or a soil study?
Dreiym's licensed Professional Engineers sample and test soil along a route, measure resistivity in the field, and design corrosion control for buried pipe.
Assumptions and limits
Point table: as published free by DIPRA® (Corrosion Control: Polyethylene Encasement, last revised January 2017, page 7), which says it is the procedure in the appendix of ANSI®/AWWA C105/A21.5, and by EPRI® (report 3002005294, Table 9-3, labelled C105/A21.5-18). We have not read the current C105 edition itself, which is sold by AWWA®. The system is written for cast and ductile iron pipe.
Edges: where a value sits exactly on a shared band edge, the tool uses the band that ends at that value and says so.
What this does not check: stray current, microbiologically influenced corrosion, changes in soil along the route, coating damage, or how the soil was sampled.
Screening tool: For education and planning. Not a corrosion study or a design, and not a substitute for a licensed engineer's review.
How the calculation works
- Resistivity: below 1,500 Ω·cm 10 points; 1,500 to 1,800: 8; above 1,800 to 2,100: 5; above 2,100 to 2,500: 2; above 2,500 to 3,000: 1; above 3,000: 0.
- pH: 0 to 2: 5; 2 to 4: 3; 4 to 6.5: 0; 6.5 to 7.5: 0, or 3 with sulfides present and low or negative redox; 7.5 to 8.5: 0; above 8.5: 3.
- Redox: above +100 mV: 0; +50 to +100: 3.5; 0 to +50: 4; negative: 5.
- Sulfides: positive 3.5; trace 2; negative 0. Moisture: poor drainage, continuously wet 2; fair, generally moist 1; good, generally dry 0.
- Ten points or more: corrosive to ductile iron pipe. A missing test counts at its highest possible value in the "most possible" figure.
Sources
Sources: DIPRA®, Corrosion Control: Polyethylene Encasement (Ductile Iron Pipe Research Association, last revised January 2017), page 7 and case histories; EPRI®, Soil Sampling and Testing Methods to Evaluate the Corrosivity of the Environment for Buried Piping and Tanks at Nuclear Power Plants, report 3002005294 (2015, correction notice 8 May 2025), Tables 2-1 and 9-3; UFC 3-570-06 (US Department of Defense, 2019), Table 4-1; Bureau of Reclamation, Technical Memorandum 8540-2024-13, Corrosion Mitigation for Buried Metallic Water Pipe (draft for review, October 2025), Table 1.
Cite or share this tool
Dreiym Engineering. Soil corrosivity calculator. Method: 10-point soil evaluation (DIPRA® 2017; EPRI® 3002005294 Table 9-3) and five resistivity scales. https://www.dreiym.com/soil-corrosivity-calculator/
Instructors and shops are welcome to link to this tool or put its address on a handout. It is free, needs no sign-up and works on a phone.
Link copied.Citation copied.The copy did not work. The text is selected, so copy it with your device.AccessedHow to use the calculator
Enter the results you have and leave the rest empty. The result gives the points for each factor, the total, and the most the total could reach once the missing tests are done, so an incomplete set of tests is never read as a low score. The table under the result places your resistivity on five published scales.
How to score soil corrosivity with the 10-point system
- Sample at pipe depth. DIPRA® recommends taking the soil sample at the depth of the pipe rather than at the surface, because readings can vary substantially between the two.
- Measure the resistivity saturated. The points are based on a water-saturated soil box, which gives the lowest reading.
- Test pH, redox and sulfides. A laboratory or field kit gives pH, the redox potential in millivolts and a positive, trace or negative sulfide result.
- Note the drainage. Poor drainage and continuously wet, fair and generally moist, or good and generally dry.
- Add the points and look beyond them. Ten points or more rates the soil corrosive to ductile iron pipe. DIPRA® adds that stray direct current and experience with nearby underground structures should also be considered.
How the 10-point score works
| Factor | Result | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Resistivity, Ω·cm | Below 1,500 / 1,500 to 1,800 / above 1,800 to 2,100 / above 2,100 to 2,500 / above 2,500 to 3,000 / above 3,000 | 10 / 8 / 5 / 2 / 1 / 0 |
| pH | 0 to 2 / 2 to 4 / 4 to 6.5 / 6.5 to 7.5 / 7.5 to 8.5 / above 8.5 | 5 / 3 / 0 / 0 or 3 / 0 / 3 |
| Redox potential, mV | Above +100 / +50 to +100 / 0 to +50 / negative | 0 / 3.5 / 4 / 5 |
| Sulfides | Positive / trace / negative | 3.5 / 2 / 0 |
| Moisture | Poor drainage, continuously wet / fair drainage, generally moist / good drainage, generally dry | 2 / 1 / 0 |
pH 6.5 to 7.5 scores 3 points instead of 0 when sulfides are present and the redox potential is low (below 100 mV) or negative. Point values as published by DIPRA® in Corrosion Control: Polyethylene Encasement (copyright 2017 DIPRA®), which says the system is in the appendix of ANSI®/AWWA C105/A21.5, and by EPRI® in report 3002005294, Table 9-3 (copyright 2015 EPRI®), which labels it C105/A21.5-18. We reproduce the point values as data with these citations; the standard itself is sold by AWWA® and we have not read it.
The table has changed. In May 2025 EPRI® corrected its report: the resistivity bands it first printed in 2015 (below 700 Ω·cm for 10 points, down to 0 points above 2,000) were those of the 1993 edition, and recent editions use the bands above. A soil of 1,600 Ω·cm earns 8 points on the current bands and 1 point on the 1993 ones.
Why resistivity scales disagree
| Scale | Bands, Ω·cm | Written for |
|---|---|---|
| 10-point system, current bands (DIPRA® 2017; EPRI® Table 9-3) | Points from 10 below 1,500 to 0 above 3,000 | Cast and ductile iron pipe |
| 10-point system, 1993 bands (EPRI® correction notice, 2025) | Points from 10 below 700 to 0 above 2,000 | Cast and ductile iron pipe |
| UFC 3-570-06 (2019), Table 4-1 | Severely corrosive 0 to 500; very 500 to 999; corrosive 1,000 to 2,999; moderately 3,000 to 9,999; slightly 10,000 to 25,000; relatively less above 25,000 | Scheduling repairs to buried and submerged metal structures |
| EPRI® 3002005294 (2015), Table 2-1 | Extremely corrosive below 500; very 500 to 1,000; corrosive 1,000 to 10,000; moderately 10,000 to 20,000; progressively less above 20,000 | Carbon steel |
| Reclamation TM 8540-2024-13, Table 1 (draft, October 2025) | 25 points at 500 or less; 20 to 2,000; 15 to 5,000; 10 to 10,000; 0 above 10,000 | Buried metallic water pipe, one factor of several |
The scales disagree because they were written for different metals and different decisions: points in a system for iron pipe, classes for carbon steel, or a priority for repair work. They also assume different measurements, from a saturated soil box to field readings. The Reclamation draft lists six more published scales in its own review. So the class of a soil depends on whose scale you read, and a single resistivity value is never the whole answer.
Is the 10-point method reliable?
The method is debated, and the two sides are trade associations of competing pipe materials. DIPRA®, the ductile iron pipe association, writes that the system has proved invaluable in surveying more than 100 million feet of proposed pipelines, while stating that it is a guide for qualified engineers or technicians. The Uni-Bell PVC Pipe Association, in Lessons Learned from Iron Pipe, Volume 6, states that the 10-point method is not a reliable indicator of the risk of corrosion, citing 60 incidents of ductile iron pipe corrosion.
Agencies have moved toward broader methods. EPRI® notes that the C105 values are only relevant for buried cast and ductile iron. The Bureau of Reclamation’s October 2025 draft memorandum replaces its resistivity-based method of 2004 with points for resistivity, chlorides, sulfates, pH and drainage, weighed against the consequences of a failure. The draft is out for review and is not Reclamation policy.
How the soil is tested
Resistivity is measured in the field with the Wenner four-pin method and in the laboratory in a soil box; pH, redox and sulfides come from samples. Our Wenner workbench plots and fits field readings, and our article on the different methods of soil testing describes the tests.
Worked example
DIPRA®’s Fayetteville, Arkansas case history, a 12-inch gray iron pipe in dark gray clay:
- Resistivity 1,600 Ω·cm: above 1,500 and not above 1,800, 8 points.
- pH 6.8: in the 6.5 to 7.5 band, with sulfides present and a negative redox potential, 3 points.
- Redox −100 mV: negative, 5 points.
- Sulfides positive: 3.5 points. Moisture saturated: 2 points.
- Total 21.5 points, the total DIPRA® prints. Ten points or more: corrosive to ductile iron pipe.
A hypothetical case, not a real site: only resistivity (2,400 Ω·cm) and drainage (fair, generally moist) are known. That is 2 + 1 = 3 points, but the missing tests could add up to 13.5 more, so the score is incomplete, not low.
Method and sources
- DIPRA®, Corrosion Control: Polyethylene Encasement (Ductile Iron Pipe Research Association, last revised January 2017), page 7, Soil Test Evaluation for Ductile Iron Pipe (10-Point System), and the case histories on pages 8 to 12. Copyright 2017 DIPRA®; point values reproduced as data with citation.
- EPRI®, Soil Sampling and Testing Methods to Evaluate the Corrosivity of the Environment for Buried Piping and Tanks at Nuclear Power Plants, report 3002005294 (November 2015), Tables 2-1 and 9-3, with the correction notice of 8 May 2025. Copyright 2015 EPRI®, free public download; values reproduced as data with citation.
- UFC 3-570-06, Operation and Maintenance: Cathodic Protection Systems (US Department of Defense, 15 July 2019), Table 4-1. Approved for public release, distribution unlimited.
- Bureau of Reclamation, Technical Memorandum 8540-2024-13, Corrosion Mitigation for Buried Metallic Water Pipe (draft for independent and public review, October 2025), Table 1. A US Government work.
- Uni-Bell PVC Pipe Association, Lessons Learned from Iron Pipe, Volume 6, for the debate section.
- Left out for lack of a free source: the redox reference-electrode correction and the current edition of ANSI®/AWWA C105/A21.5 itself. Method last checked against these sources on 19 November 2026.
Verified against
| DIPRA® case history (2017) | Soil | DIPRA® total | This calculator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Merritt Island, FL | 1,120 Ω·cm, pH 7.1, redox −20 mV | 23.5 | 23.5 |
| Waterford, MI | 960 Ω·cm, pH 7.5, redox +23 mV | 22 | 22.5 (DIPRA® gives +23 mV 3.5 points; its table gives 4) |
| Ogden, UT | 192 Ω·cm, pH 7.9, redox −165 mV | 20.5 | 20.5 |
| Mitchell, SD | 840 Ω·cm, pH 7.1, redox +450 mV | 13 | 13 |
| Detroit, MI | 1,320 Ω·cm, pH 7.4, redox −113 mV | 23.5 | 23.5 |
| Omaha, NE | 600 Ω·cm, pH 7.4, redox +90 mV | 22 | 22 |
| Charleston, SC | 560 Ω·cm, pH 6.9, redox −132 mV | 23.5 | 23.5 |
| Syracuse, NY | 410 Ω·cm, pH 6.9, redox −40 mV | 23.5 | 23.5 |
| Fayetteville, AR | 1,600 Ω·cm, pH 6.8, redox −100 mV | 21.5 | 21.5 |
| Jackson, MS | 880 Ω·cm, pH 4.4, redox −150 mV | 20.5 | 20.5 |
| Little Rock, AR | 600 Ω·cm, pH 6.9, redox +40 mV | 21 | 21 |
| Montgomery, AL | 172 Ω·cm, pH 8.7, redox +30 mV | 19 | 19 |
| Lafourche Parish, LA | 520 Ω·cm, pH 6.3, redox −50 mV | 20.5 | 20.5 |
| Latham, NY | 600 Ω·cm, pH 7.1, redox +200 mV | 12 | 12 |
| St. George, UT | 720 Ω·cm, pH 7.3, redox +110 mV | 12 | 12 |
| City of Orange, CA | 640 Ω·cm, pH 6.3, redox +170 mV | 12 | 12 |
| St. Louis, MO | 600 Ω·cm, pH 6.7, redox +150 mV | 11 | 11 |
| Nanticoke, ON | 960 Ω·cm, pH 7.3, redox −18 mV | 23.5 | 23.5 |
| Farmington/Shiprock, NM | 400 Ω·cm, pH 7.7, redox +146 mV | 14 | 14 |
All nineteen single-value case histories in the brochure are checked; the Philadelphia case gives ranges and is left out. These cases are part of the unit tests that run every time the calculator is built.
Frequently asked questions
What is the 10-point soil test evaluation?
A scoring system for the corrosivity of soil to cast and ductile iron pipe. Resistivity, pH, redox potential, sulfides and moisture each earn points, and a total of 10 or more rates the soil corrosive to ductile iron pipe. DIPRA® says it is in the appendix of ANSI®/AWWA C105/A21.5.
What soil resistivity is corrosive?
It depends on the scale. UFC 3-570-06 calls 1,000 to 2,999 ohm-cm corrosive and below 500 severely corrosive; EPRI® calls 1,000 to 10,000 ohm-cm corrosive for carbon steel; the 10-point system gives points below 3,000 ohm-cm. The calculator shows the five scales side by side.
Is the 10-point system reliable?
It is debated. DIPRA® reports wide use over decades and calls it a guide for qualified engineers. The Uni-Bell PVC Pipe Association states it is not a reliable indicator of corrosion risk, citing 60 ductile iron pipe corrosion incidents. Both are pipe industry associations.
Why does the calculator ask for a saturated resistivity?
DIPRA® bases the points on a water-saturated soil box reading, which gives the lowest value. A field reading in dry weather can be higher and would score fewer points.
Does a score under 10 mean the pipe will not corrode?
No. The score does not cover stray current, and DIPRA® adds that stray direct current and experience with nearby underground structures should also be considered. Soils also change along a route.
When to bring in an engineer
A score helps decide where to test more. Corrosion control for a pipeline is designed from the soil along the whole route, the pipe, and the consequences of a failure. Dreiym’s licensed Professional Engineers provide soil corrosivity analysis and forensic corrosion engineering. Read more on what determines how corrosive soil is, soil resistivity and corrosion, how soil resistivity affects pipes and CP in high-resistivity soils, or try the cathodic protection calculator.
More engineering tools
All calculatorsNeed more than a screening estimate?
We typically respond within one business day.